Talk:WikiJournal Preprints/Immune system
Add topic
This article is an unpublished pre-print undergoing public peer review organised by the WikiJournal of Medicine.
It is adapted from the Wikipedia page Immune system. It contains some or all of that page's content licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution ShareAlike License and will also be used to update that article after peer review.You can follow its progress through the peer review process at this tracking page.First submitted:
Article text
QID: Q116734788
Suggested (provisional) preprint citation format:
Sarmoko; Muhammad Novrizal Abdi Sahid. "Immune system". WikiJournal Preprints. Wikidata Q116734788.
License: 
This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution ShareAlike License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction, provided the original author and source are credited.
Roger Watson 
contact
Mark Hayter
Article information
Submitting authors: Sarmoko[a][i] , Muhammad Novrizal Abdi Sahid[b]
Additional contributors: Wikipedia community
This is the pre-publication public peer review for the article Immune system
Plagiarism check
[edit source]Report from the WMF copyvios tool flagged 96.9% with 'violations suspected' with regard to plagiarism. Please see the results here [1] Rwatson1955 (discuss • contribs)
First peer review
[edit source]
Review by Mark Hayter 
, Manchester Metropolitan University
These assessment comments were submitted on , and refer to this previous version of the article
This is a very well written and sourced piece of work. It is written in an understandable manner and is accurate to the best of my knowledge. My only comment would be that there could be a better description and cross referencing to the innate response when antigen presenting cells are discussed - that section is a bit light and could be clearer. I would like to see this article after author responses.
Editorial comment
[edit source]The decision was taken not to continue with reviewing manuscript; the high level of similarity was to a range of sites and the relationship to the Wikipedia age on Immune System was bit clear. Efforts were made to seek clarification from the corresponding author, to no avail. Rwatson1955 (discuss • contribs) 09:43, 19 May 2023 (UTC)
- Dear Dr. Roger Watson,
- I hope this comment reply finds you well. I am writing to inform you that I have recently changed institutions, which has resulted in a disruption in communication via the email address associated with this manuscript. Fortunately, I came across this page and would like to take this opportunity to address a few points.
- I am one of the contributors to the Immune System Wikipedia page and subsequently developed a manuscript based on its content. Regarding the similarity results, I would like to note that the Immune System page is a featured article. As stated in the similarity results, "Be aware that other websites can copy from Wikipedia, so check the results carefully, especially for older or well-developed articles."
- While all Wikimedia Foundation (WMF) pages have been excluded from the WMF copyvios, it appears that other websites have copied content from Wikipedia, resulting in their appearance within the top three results.
- In light of this, I can prepare the new version of the Immune System manuscript that will be distinct from the existing Wikipedia page.
- I kindly request your decision and guidance regarding this matter. Should you require further information or clarification, please do not hesitate to reach me at sarmoko@gmail.com.
- Thank you for your attention to this matter. Helito (discuss • contribs) 13:58, 27 May 2023 (UTC)
- @Helito:, flagging your response to Rwatson1955. I do note that this possibility exists and has occurred in the past. OhanaUnitedTalk page 19:58, 7 September 2023 (UTC)
Editorial reply
[edit source]- Hi
- I think we corresponded on email about this last year - feel free to prepare a new version and let me know when that is done. 5.198.83.94 (discuss) 13:14, 18 January 2024 (UTC)