Motivation and emotion/Assessment/Chapter/Feedback
Appearance
General feedback about
book chapters
book chapters
|
Overall
[edit | edit source]- The overall quality of chapters was reasonably good, but there was a notably wide range in quality from poor to outstanding
- The most common issues were:
- Not directly addressing the topic (as specified in the title and sub-title)
- Making unacknowledged overuse use of genAI, rather than prioritising human writing based on reading of original sources
- Insufficient review and synthesis of the best research about the topic (weaker chapters were commonly theory-heavy and research-light)
- No or minimal engagement in making social contributions with direct links to evidence
Overview
[edit | edit source]- The best overviews consisted of:
- A scenario/case study which appealed to a broad audience in a feature box with a relevant image
- A straighforward, compelling description of the psychological problem or phenomenon
- Clear and relevant focus questions that closely aligned with the top-level headings.
Theory
[edit | edit source]- Most chapters used a well-selected range of relevant theories
- Theories were generally well explained, but stronger chapters exhibit more incisive theoretical depth based on reading and understanding of primary sources
- Almost chapters could be improved by more strongly embedding links to related chapters
- The strongest chapters illustrated theoretical princples through practical examples
Research
[edit | edit source]- Depth of critical review of research was the single most distinguishing characteristic of the strongest chapters
- Most chapters reviewed some relevant research, but often the review of research could have been more relevant and/or indepth
- More emphasis should have been placed on major reviews such as meta-analyses
- To improve critical review of research, for key studies, report details about the sample, country, method, and strength of observed effects
- Weaker chapters often lacked sufficient citation of academic peer-reviewed sources to support claims
Integration
[edit | edit source]- The best chapters had excellent integration between theory and research
- Weakers chapters tended to rely more heavily on theory than research, or covered research as a stand-alone topic rather than integrated review that synthesised theory and research
Conclusion
[edit | edit source]- Often the weaker conclusions read like generic genAI summaries
- The best chapters addressed the focus questions and provided explicit take-home messages
Style
[edit | edit source]Written expression
[edit | edit source]- The overall quality of written expression was reasonably good, but varied widely
- The most common problems were:
- grammar and spelling
- poor grammar—there's many ways to get help to develop professional-level written expression (e.g., Studiosity, genAI)
- use 3rd person, rather than 1st person, perspective[1]
- use past tense when describing research studies, although implications of findings could be in the present tense
- use serial commas[2] (they are part of APA style)
- use ownership (possessive) apostrophes
- Use Australian spelling.
- insufficient citation—psychological science community requires claims to be supported by cited evidence and sources
- grammar and spelling
- The most common APA style reference formatting areas for improvement were:
- capitalisation
- italicisation
Learning features
[edit | edit source]- The use of learning features varied widely between chapters
- The best chapters were interconnected with other Wikimedia resources by using:
- embedded interwiki links to Wikipedia articles help to connect reader to further information about key concepts
- embedded interwiki links to related Wikiversity book chapters
- Figures were reasonably well used, with many students uploading and contributing their own images (thankyou!)
- Tables were less commonly used, but were strongest when thoughtfully constructed and weaker when constructed by genAI and lacking in acknowledgement of sources
- Additional scenarios/case studies in feature boxes were underused to provide illustrative examples
- The best chapters used distributed quiz questions about take-home messages rather than being presented at the end
Social contributions
[edit | edit source]- The amount and quality of contributions varied widely: The use of social contributions distinguished sharply between genuinely and casually engaged authors—some students made no contributions whilst some excelled and were awarded bonus marks
- Many valuable improvements were made to past and current chapters
- Unless there were direct links to evidence, no marks were provided