Talk:WikiJournal Preprints/Kinematics of the cuboctahedron
Add topicThis article is an unpublished pre-print undergoing public peer review organised by the WikiJournal of Science.
It is adapted from the Wikipedia page Kinematics of the cuboctahedron. It contains some or all of that page's content licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution ShareAlike License and will also be used to update that article after peer review.You can follow its progress through the peer review process at this tracking page.First submitted:
QID: Q131333821
Suggested (provisional) preprint citation format:
David Brooks Christie. "Kinematics of the cuboctahedron". WikiJournal Preprints. Wikidata Q131333821.
License: CC-BY-SA 4.0
Editors:Kevin M. Moerman
contact
Andrew Leung
contact
Tuyen Trung Truong
Article information
This is the pre-publication public peer review for the article Kinematics of the cuboctahedron

Tadeusz E. Dorozinski, CC-BY 3.0
Peer review 1
[edit source]
Review by Trung Tuyen Truong
, University of Oslo
These assessment comments were submitted on , and refer to this previous version of the article
In this paper, the author considers the question of transforming the cuboctahedron (concerning only the vertices and edges, and not the surfaces) – sometimes subdivision is allowed – to other 3D shapes.
Here are some comments which can help improve the paper:
Many times the author mentions names of theoretical stuffs, e.g. pyritohedral symmetry of the icosahedron, and then refer to another link. While it is not advisable to include everything in the paper, for the convenience of readers the paper should be as self-contained as possible for the special situation dealt with in the paper. The same comment for sentences such as: “Topologically the transformation follows a Möbius loop: it is an orientable double cover of the octahedron. Physically it is a spinor.” In these two sentences, there are many undefined terms, also a bit confusion. Before there, the “transformation” is understood as the movement from cuboctahedron, regular icosahedron, Jessen’s icosahedron and Regular octahedron, and again to cubotahedron cyclically. In these two sentences, the author seems to only mean the map from cuboctahedron. The reader may wonder what can be said about the map from Cuboctahedron to Regular icosahedron, or from Jessen’s icosahedron to Regular octahedron.
The legend for Figure 2 is too long.
The author may explain what “Rigid-edge transformation” is. I understand that it means the lengths of the edges are fixed, but the positions can be changed, but it is better to make things unambiguous in a scientific paper.
Similar for “elastic-edge transformation”. Again, “infinitesimal mobility”: what are the rules to perform this?
Most importantly: while the author included animation (very helpful!) to illustrate the theoretical results, the actual theoretical content is referred to other places. The author should make this self-sufficient to some levels, and should provide some sketch of ideas for why the theoretical results mentioned in the paper should be true. Of course, since this is not a paper to be published in a journal, it should not be written in a very long and heavy style, but it still should provide enough ideas for readers to get away even if they do not look at the pointers.