Jump to content

Motivation and emotion/Assessment/Topic/Feedback

From Wikiversity
Topic development - General feedback

This page summarises general feedback about the topic development submissions. Read this general feedback in conjunction with individual feedback placed on each topic's discussion page.

Title and sub-title

[edit | edit source]
  1. The title and sub-title should match the exact wording and casing listed in the book's table of contents; any changes should be negotiated.
  2. Don't display user name – authorship is as per the page's editing history (there are likely multiple contributors).

Headings

[edit | edit source]
  1. The best structures are usually 2-levels with 3 to 6 main body top-level headings between the Overview and Conclusion and, for longer sections, 2 to 5 sub-headings.
  2. The best structures exhibit close alignment between the sub-title question(s), focus questions, and top-level headings.
  3. Stronger topic development proposals tend to use more descriptives headings, however aren't overly complicated. Humans tend to create overly short headings whereas genAI LLM tools tend to create overly long headings.
  4. Headings should use sentence casing (i.e., lower-case except for the first letter and proper nouns).

Overview

[edit | edit source]
  1. The best topic developments start with a short scenario and corresponding figure in a feature box, then briefly describe the problem/phenomenon from a psychological point of view, and finish with well-honed focus questions that unpack the sub-title in a feature box.

Key points

[edit | edit source]
  1. The best submissions develop at least three key points per section with citations to the best psychological theory and research about the topic.
  2. Submissions with limited or missing development of key points indicate insufficient understanding of the topic.
  3. A plan for the Conclusion (the most important section) was often missing or underdeveloped.
  4. When a section has sub-sections, provide an introductory paragraph before the first sub-heading.
  5. Many submissions could be improved by using Studiosity, Grammarly, and/or other tools such as generative artificial intelligence (genAI) large language models to correct grammatical and spelling errors and to improve the quality of written expression.
  6. However, overreliance on genAI commonly leads to issues such as overly complicated heading structures, overly broad and overly specific focus questions, overly comprehensive details, and plans that do not show that the author has an indepth understanding of the best psychological theory and research about the topic.
  7. Use of genAI content needs to be acknowledged in edit summaries, otherwise it risks triggering learning validation conversations and referrals for summary inquiries for violating principles of academic integrity.

Figure

[edit | edit source]
  1. Almost all topic developments included a relevant image.
  2. Most figure captions could be improved by expanding them to a make clearer connection to key points in the main text.
  3. Cite each figure at least once using APA style (e.g., see Figure 1).

Learning feature

[edit | edit source]
  1. The best topic developments use at least one out of the following learning features:
    1. multiple embedded interwiki links for the first mention of key words to relevant book chapters and/or Wikipedia articles
    2. examples/scenarios/case studies (often more examples would improve the chapter). The best scenarios show theory in action through real-world type scenarios.
    3. figures
    4. quiz questions about the take-away message(s) (avoid placing these in a stand-alone section at the end – instead, embed each question(s) within the relevant section)

References

[edit | edit source]
  1. Very few submissions use perfect APA style (7th ed.) for citations and references.
  2. The most common issues are:
    1. incorrect capitalisation
    2. incorrect italicisation
    3. providing dois as plain text rather than as active hyperlinks
  3. The best submissions include relevant systematic reviews or meta-analyses.

Resources

[edit | edit source]
  1. See also
    1. The best topic developments provide interwiki links to at least one Wikipedia and at least one Wikiversity page, using bullet points, with source information in brackets - e.g., (Wikipedia) or (Book chapter, 2025).
  2. External links
    1. Include source in brackets after the link - e.g., (YouTube).
    2. Ensure relevance to an international audience.

User page

[edit | edit source]
  1. Generally used effectively, with a self-introduction and link to book chapter.
  2. The main area for potential improvement are expanding information about the user.
  3. Consider linking to your professional online profile(s) — the most effective professional networking strategy is to do interesting things and share them publicly[1].

Social contribution

[edit | edit source]
  1. Sometimes three of the same type of contributions are made rather than demonstrating an ability to make three different types of contribution:
    1. Direct edit to improve a past or present chapter.
    2. Comment on the talk page of a past or present chapter.
    3. Post to an external discussion platform about the topic or unit (e.g., UCLearn discussion of #emot24 on X).
  2. Only direct links to evidence are counted for marking purposes. To create a direct link to Wikiversity edits, view the page history, select the version of the page before and after your contributions, click "compare selected revisions", and then copy this website address to your user page. For more info, see the book chapter author guidelines.