Motivation and emotion/Book/2023/Irrational belief motivation

Irrational belief motivation:
What motivates irrational beliefs?

Overview

Case study

Maddie and Alex have met in their first year at university, and have become very close friends. They are currently in their final year, and are enrolled in the same units. They have not seen each other in a while, so they decide to meet after class. Mid-semester exams are stressful for both of them, especially since it is their last year before graduating! However, Maddie knows that she and Alex are good students, and, so far, they have been doing well academically. When discussing their workload, Alex says "I must get high distinctions on all my units this semester, otherwise I am a failure". Alex's words seem harsh and unrealistic to Maddie. Surely, she also cares about receiving good grades this semester, but believing that receiving anything less than a high distinction makes Alex a failure seems illogical and unrealistic to her. Why is Alex feeling this way?

irrationality has been explored since the dawn of ancient philosophy. Most notably, 19th century philosophy tried to paint irrationality as a useful tool to understand the world, considered to be more effective than rational knowledge (Klimets, 2004). However, psychology views irrationality as "the state, condition, or quality of lacking rational thought ... typically used in relation to cognitive behaviour (e.g., thinking, decision making) that is illogical or delusional" (APA Dictionary of Psychology, n.d.). Contrary to what the 19th century philosophers believed, psychological research has established a link between irrational beliefs and distress, as experiencing irrational beliefs can lead individuals to interpret events in a negative and self-defeating way (Bridges & Harnish, 2010).

Studies on various mental disorders have been able to establish that irrational beliefs play a primary role in the development of anxiety and depression (see Figure 1) (Bridges & Harnish, 2010). Understanding the causes of psychological disturbance and helping people feel better has been the rationale behind the development of new forms of therapy, such as Rational Emotive Behaviour Therapy - a precursor to today's Cognitive Behavioural therapy (Collard & O'Kelly, 2011; Ellis, 2004). These approaches distinguish themselves from other cognitive-behavioural approaches because they set rational and irrational beliefs at the core of their research (Turner, 2016).

This chapter draws from psychological and sociological theory, as well as research, to understand the characteristics of irrational beliefs, what motivates them and what individuals can do to alleviate distress when they experience irrational thoughts.

Focus questions

What is an irrational belief?
How are irrational beliefs related to distress?
What motivates irrational beliefs?
How can irrational beliefs be changed?

Types of irrational beliefs

Understanding irrational beliefs is tackled by many areas of behavioural science, mainly because irrationality appears to be experienced across all social and cultural groups (Gkontelos et al.,2021). Rational emotional belief therapy (REBT) helps people deal and manage irrational beliefs that are presented in every day life (Ellis et al., 2009). An irrational belief is decribed as non-pragmatic, illogical and lacking evidence surrounding the emotional thought. Where as a rational belief, is pragmatic, logical and reality-based (Ellis et al., 2009), (Gkontelos et al.,2021). Additionally, irrational thoughts are often associated with dysfunctional behaviours and consequences (Gkontelos et al.,2021).

The most common irrational beliefs outlined by REBT are demandingness, depreciation, frustration intolerance (or low frustration tolerance) and awfulising.[factual?]

Demandingness

Demandingness is a primary irrational belief because it can predict secondary irrational beliefs (Mansell & Turner 2022; Buschmann et al., 2018). It is characterised by absolute expressions, often prefaced with 'must' and 'should'. Demanding expressions set themselves apart from rational beliefs because they are often maladaptive demands to one's performance (Mansell & Turner 2022; Tóth et al., 2022).

Depreciation

Depreciation is characterised by negative evaluations of the self, leading to lower self-confidence (Mansell & Turner 2022; Buschmann et al., 2018). Depreciation can be related to the self (self-depreciation) or others (other-depreciation) (Turner, 2016).

Frustration intolerance

Frustration intolerance is experienced when individuals believe that they are unable to tolerate conditions of adversity (Mansell & Turner 2022). It can lead to procrastination when accompanied by boring and difficult tasks (Turner, 2016).

Awfulising

Awfulising beliefs occur when the individual aggravates the status of currently unpleasant events (Mansell & Turner 2022). It is positively related to a submissive interpersonal style (Turner, 2016).

Case study

Alex

Thinks he must get a high distinction in his units.
Thinks that if he gets a credit, he is a failure.
Believes that it would be unbearable to get less than a high distinction.
Believes that failing would be the worst thing that could happen to him.

Maddie

Knows that learning is more important, even if she does not achieve the highest mark.
Understands that not succeeding does not make her a failure.
Understands that failure is not unbearable.
Acknowledges that any receiving a grade that is lower than what she expects is not the worst thing that could happen to her.

Quiz

Irrational beliefs and distress

Considerable research has pointed to a link between irrational beliefs and mental disorders. According to REBT, distress is not caused by particular situations, but by the individual's own evaluation of such situations (Chan & Sun, 2021). The rigidity and awfulising nature of irrational beliefs lead to emotional disturbance which can affect individuals' wellbeing (Chan & Sun, 2021).

Depression

Considerable research has pointed to a link between irrational beliefs, depression and anxiety. According to REBT, irrational beliefs can lead to automatic thoughts, which are negative in nature and can manifest unconsciously (e.g. "I am not good enough"), further leading to mental distress (APA Dictionary of Psychology, n.d; Buschmann et al., 2018). However, research has also pointed to some inconsistencies in the mediational role of automatic beliefs, suggesting that irrational beliefs may be directly connected to depressive symptoms (Buschmann et al., 2018). Buschmann et al. (2018) used self-reporting measures to investigate the relationship between irrational beliefs, automatic thoughts and depression. The study found that, when participants experienced stress, irrational beliefs led to more automatic thoughts which ultimately increased depressive symptoms (Buschmann et al., 2018).

Anger and aggression

REBT theory suggests that irrational beliefs are positively related to anger (Fives et al., 2011). A study by Martin and Dahler (2004) examined the relationship between irrational beliefs outlined by REBT and anger, by measuring participants' trait anger expression, personal beliefs and hostility through self-reporting scales. The study found that awfulising and frustration intolerance were related to aggressive expressions of anger, with the former being also related to the inability to control outwardly expressions of anger (Martin & Dahler, 2004). Additionally, the study also observed that depreciation may be related to derogatory thoughts (Martin & Dahler, 2004).

Moreover, REBT theory suggests that - when combined with irrational beliefs - anger can also lead to aggressive behaviours (Fives et al., 2011). A study by Fives et al. (2011) targeted adolescents from grades 9 to 12 to understand whether irrational beliefs could lead to aggression when combined with anger. Using self-reporting scales to assess irrational beliefs and aggression, the study found that while anger alone could predict verbal aggression when combined with irrational beliefs it could also predict physical aggression (Fives et al., 2011).

Psychological motivators

Identifying what irrational beliefs are and the distress that originates from them can be useful in establishing a connection between cognitions, emotions and behaviours. However, to comprehensively understand irrational beliefs, it is necessary to also point out what motivates them. Studies that investigate the origins of irrational beliefs date back to ancient Asian, Greek and Roman philosophers (Ellis, 2008). Epictetus, for example, believed that individuals are not only disturbed by what happens to them, but by their view on the events (Ellis, 2008). When Albert Ellis started creating REBT in 1953, he realised that the psychoanalytical theories of the time failed to explore why people experienced distress (Ellis, 2004). Ellis believed that all humans possess self-defeating tendencies and self-enhancing tendencies, which translate respectively into rationality and irrationality (Bernard et al., 2010). Leveraging on Epictetus' theory, REBT affirms that irrational beliefs can result from biological (patterns of thinking and behaving) factors (Browne et al., 2010).

Maladaptive schemas

Maladaptive schemas are self-defeating cognitive and emotional patterns that are repeated throughout life (Gholamzadeh et al., 2015). Beck (2008) hypothesised that challenging and stressful situations may lead to the activation of rigid and inflexible schemas, which ultimately influence the way information is evaluated and processed, leading to the formation of irrational beliefs (Buschmann et al., 2018). A study by Turner et al. (2019) investigated the relationship between irrational beliefs and maladaptive schemas in athletes, who are often exposed to high demands and pressures, which can negatively impact their mental health. The study found that athletes' maladaptive schemas mediated the relationship between irrational beliefs and distress, meaning that, when maladaptive schemas were introduced in the study, there was little evidence to suggest that irrational beliefs could influence athletes' distress on their own (Turner et al., 2019).

Similarly, Bidari et al. (2021) examined the relationship between schemas and irrational beliefs by analysing the effects of schema therapy on the irrational beliefs of women with marital conflict who showed signs of early maladaptive schemata. The goal of schema therapy is to identify and reduce unhealthy coping behaviours, which often perpetuate maladaptive schemas, and replace them with healthier and more adaptive schemas (Masley et al., 2012). The study showed that schema therapy successfully decreased the number of irrational beliefs experienced by the study's target population (Bidari et al., 2021). These results appear to suggest that maladaptive schemas may be a key motivator to explain the formation of irrational beliefs and their effects on well-being.

Heuristics

Heuristics are mental shortcuts that can facilitate information processing as they are quick, demand fewer resources and are usually beneficial for fast decision-making (Barlev & Neuberg, 2022; Lambos & Delfabbro, 2007). However, quick decision-making and information processing can often lead to misinformation and a distorted view of the world (Barlev & Neuberg, 2022). The influence of heuristics on irrational beliefs can often be observed in pathological gamblers, who tend to persist in their goal of winning despite suffering heavy losses (Lambos & Delfabbro, 2007). Lambos and Delfabbro (2007) theorised that pathological gamblers would showcase a higher number of irrational beliefs (in this case, related to perceived control and outcomes) regardless of their knowledge of general gambling odds and their reasoning abilities. The study was able to confirm this theory, as regardless of their education and mathematical literacy, pathological gamblers were likely to become susceptible to cognitive biases and present a higher number of irrational beliefs compared to less frequent gamblers (Lambos & Delfabbro, 2007). Results from this study suggest that even when provided with accurate and thorough information, cognitive biases can have a negative impact on rationality.

Personality traits

Research on personality has shown that personality traits can have a direct effect on how individuals cope with life events (Kabarsakal & Aydin, 2023). For example, studies have shown that the autonomic personality trait often leads to the development of useful problem-solving skills and psychological resilience among individuals (Kabarsakal & Aydin, 2023). Nevertheless, the relationship between personality traits and irrational beliefs has been severely underexplored by psychological research, as therapies such as REBT try to develop more adaptive ways of thinking without taking into account personality differences (Samar et al., 2013). Samar et al. (2013) investigated a possible connection between irrational beliefs and the five-factor model (FFM) of personality traits, to understand whether personality may motivate the development of rational or irrational beliefs. The study sampled a group of undergraduate students, measuring their irrational beliefs along with the five major domains of the FFM: neuroticism, extraversion, openness, agreeableness and conscientiousness (Samar et al., 2013). The study found that most personality traits were accurate predictors of irrational beliefs - with neuroticism and openness being associated with a higher score on total irrationality - while agreeableness did not appear to show a significant connection to irrational beliefs (Samar et al., 2013).

Quiz

Sociocultural motivators

Along with biological motivators, REBT also acknowledges the role of environmental factors in developing and fostering irrational beliefs (Browne et al., 2010). Studies on the sociocultural dimension of irrational beliefs have shown that institutions, such as schools and churches, help promote irrational beliefs among their members, further arguing that when individuals operate in an environment characterised by irrational beliefs, they are more likely to also develop irrational beliefs (King et al., 2023). The behaviour of parents, for example, is a great influence on a child's self-worth, as the expression or withdrawal of affection can affect the development of irrational beliefs (King et al., 2023). In a sports environment, the language used by coaches interacting with athletes may impact the formation and expression of irrational beliefs (see Figure 2) (King et al., 2023). Evans et al. (2018) tested this hypothesis by subjecting a sample of football athletes to either rational or irrational coach talks. For the purpose of the study, the 'irrational' coach talk included statements indicative of demandingness, depreciation, awfulising and frustration intolerance (Evans et al., 2018). The results proved that, while both groups of athletes were equally motivated, those who received irrational coach talks presented a higher level of demandingness, which may suggest that they were able to internalise and adopt the coach's irrational beliefs (Evans et al., 2018).

Case study: choking under pressure

"Choking under pressure" is a great example of how environmental factors can lead to irrational beliefs. This phenomenon can usually be observed in sports, as athletes can be subjected to intense pressure to succeed and to achieve high standards, which lead to higher self-depreciation (James, 1998). Hence, athletes who experience this condition become highly conscious of what they are doing, and end up performing worse during competitions (James, 1998). Mesagno et al. (2021) conducted a study on experienced Australian football players. The athletes firstly completed an irrational belief questionnaire and then were asked to perform in both high and low pressure conditions (Mesagno et al., 2021). The study showed that the athletes who scored high on the irrational belief questionnaire performed significantly worse when they were in the high pressure condition, which may suggest that environmental factors play an important role in motivating irrational beliefs (Mesagno et al., 2021).

The ABCDE model

REBT seeks to help people who experience emotional disturbances and help them achieve their goals (Bernard et al., 2010). To do so, the theory suggests that it is necessary to develop people's potential for rationality by helping them practice rational principles of living, with a focus on short-term goals (Bernard et al., 2010). The ABCDE model represents REBT's central idea for treatment, as it empowers clients to dispute their irrational beliefs (see Figure 3) (Bernard et al., 2010). According to the model, when people are confronted with adversities (A), they can either choose to hold rational or irrational beliefs (B), which can lead to healthy or unhealthy consequences (C) (Ellis, 2008). When seeking therapy, individuals are asked to dispute (D) their irrational beliefs and are encouraged (E) to replace their irrational beliefs with rational ones (Turner et al., 2020). Turner et al. (2020) applied the ABCDE model to a group of amateur golfers with the goal of decreasing irrational beliefs, which can often lead to performance anxiety. The study found that, after the intervention, all golfers displayed a decreased number of irrational beliefs and anxiety (Turner et al., 2020). Moreover, data collected after one month from the intervention, showed persistence in the study's initial results, further suggesting that REBT can lead to long-term change (Turner et al., 2020). However, the study also acknowledges that there are several areas for improving how the effectiveness of the ABCDE model is assessed, as longer and more detailed interventions may be able to not only be more affective, but also evaluate changes over time (Turner et al., 2020).

Quiz

Conclusion

Overall, it is clear how irrational beliefs can manifest in different ways. Demanding statements (such as "I need to"), awfulising statements, frustration intolerance and low self-confidence, can negatively impact an individual's wellbeing and ability to cope with adversity. Irrational beliefs appear to be motivated by a wide range of factors, both internal and external. Maladaptive schemas, heuristics and personality traits can be crucial motivators to foster the development of irrational beliefs. However, environmental pressures can be just as important. As the phenomenon of "choking under pressure" shows, a demanding environment can affect an individual's self-confidence, leading to unsatisfactory performances. Nevertheless, new forms of therapy - such as REBT's ABCDE model - have designed interventions to help individuals be aware of their irrational beliefs and work towards establishing new rational beliefs. Findings from applications of the ABCDE model show that teaching people how to be in control of their reactions can alleviate the distress caused by irrational beliefs.

References

American Psychological Association (n.d.). Automatic thoughts. In APA Dictionary of Psychology. Retrieved September 21, 2023. https://dictionary.apa.org/automatic-thoughts

American Psychological Association (n.d.). Irrationality. In APA Dictionary of Psychology. Retrieved August 11, 2023, from https://dictionary.apa.org/irrationality

Barlev, M., & Neuberg, S.L. (2022). Deeply rational reasons for irrational beliefs. PsyArXiv. https://doi.org/10.31234/osf.io/avcq2

Bernard, M. E., Froh, J. J., Digiuseppe, R., Joyce, M. R., & Dryden, W. (2010). Albert Ellis: Unsung hero of positive psychology. The Journal of Positive Psychology, 5(4), 302–310. https://doi.org/10.1080/17439760.2010.498622

Bidari, F., Amirfakhraei, A., Zarei, E., Keramati, K. (2021). The effects of schema therapy on the irrational beliefs and emotional self-regulation of the women with marital conflict with early maladaptive schemata. Psychological achievements, 28(2). https://doi.org/10.22055/psy.2021.35143.2602

Bridges, K. R., & Harnish, R. J. (2010). Role of irrational beliefs in depression and anxiety: a review. Health, 2(8), 862–877. https://doi.org/10.4236/health.2010.28130

Browne, C.M., Dowd, E.T., Freeman, A. (2010). Rational and irrational beliefs and psychopathology. In D. David, S. J. Lynn, & A. Ellis (Eds.), Rational and irrational beliefs: Research, theory, and clinical practice (pp. 149–171). Oxford University Press.

Buschmann, T., Horn, R.A., Blankenship, V.R., Garcia, Y.E., Bohan, K.B. (2018). The relationship between automatic thoughts and irrational beliefs predicting anxiety and depression. Journal of Rational-Emotive & Cognitive-Behavior Therapy, 36(2018), 137-162. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10942-017-0278-y

Chan, H. W. Q., & Sun, C. F. R.. (2021). Irrational beliefs, depression, anxiety, and stress among university students in Hong Kong. Journal of American College Health, 69(8), 827–841. https://doi.org/10.1080/07448481.2019.1710516

Collard, J., & O’Kelly, M. (2011). Rational emotive behaviour therapy: A positive perspective. Journal of Rational-emotive & Cognitive-behavior Therapy, 29(4), 248–256. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10942-011-0146-0

Ellis, A. (2004). Why rational emotive therapy is the most comprehensive and effective form of behaviour therapy. Journal of Rational-Emotive & Cognitive-Behaviour Therapy, 22(2), 85-92. https://doi.org/10.1023/B:JORE.0000025439.78389.52

Ellis, A. (2008). Cognitive restructuring of the disputing of irrational beliefs. In W. T. O'Donohue & J. E. Fisher (Eds.), Cognitive Behavior Therapy: Applying empirically Supported Techniques in your Practice (pp. 91–95). John Wiley & Sons, Inc.

Ellis, A., David, D., Lynn, S. (2009). Rational and irrational beliefs: A historical and conceptual perspective, in D. David, S. Lynn, & A. Ellis (eds), Rational and irrational beliefs: Research, theory, and clinical practice (pp.3-22). Oxford Academic. https://doi.org/10.1093/acprof:oso/9780195182231.003.0001

Evans, A. L., Turner, M. J., Pickering, R., & Powditch, R.. (2018). The effects of rational and irrational coach team talks on the cognitive appraisal and achievement goal orientation of varsity football athletes. International Journal of Sports Science & Coaching, 13(3), 431–438. https://doi.org/10.1177/1747954118771183

Fives, C. J., Kong, G., Fuller, J. R., & Digiuseppe, R.. (2011). Anger, aggression, and irrational beliefs in adolescents. Cognitive Therapy and Research, 35(3), 199–208. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10608-009-9293-3

Gholamzadeh, H., Ramazi, M.G., Dehghan, H., Divsalar, K.(2015). The comparison of maladaptive cognitive schemas and irrational beliefs among smoker and non-smoker students. Report of Health Care, 1(3), 92-98.

Gkontelos, A., Vaiopoulou, J., & Stamovlasis, D. (2021). Teachers’ irrational belief scale: Psychometric properties of the Greek version and measurement invariance across genders. Behavioral Sciences, 11(11), 160. https://doi.org/10.3390/bs11110160

James, C.A. (1998). Irrationality in philosophy and psychology: The moral implications of self-defeating behaviour. Journal of Consciousness Studies, 5(2), 224-34.

King, A. M., Turner, M. J., Plateau, C. R., & Barker, J. B. (2023). The socialisation of athlete irrational beliefs. Journal of Rational-emotive & Cognitive-behavior Therapy, 41(2), 290–313. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10942-022-00460-4

Klimets, A. (2004). Science and irrationalism or the generalized complementarity principle of Bohr. Physics of Consciousness and Life, Cosmology and Astrophysics (Kiev), 4(2)49-63.

Lambos, C., & Delfabbro, P. (2007). Numerical reasoning ability and irrational beliefs in problem gambling. International Gambling Studies, 7(2), 157–171. https://doi.org/10.1080/14459790701387428

Mansell, P.C. & Turner, M.J. (2022). Testing the REBT-I model in athletes: Investigating the role of self-confidence between irrational beliefs and psychological distress. Psychology of Sport and Exercise, 63(2022), 1-8. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.psychsport.2022.102284

Martin, R.C., Dahlen, E.R. (2004). Irrational beliefs and the exprerience and expression of anger. Journal of Rational-Emotive & Cognitive-Behavior Therapy, 22(1), 3-20. https://doi.org/10.1023/B:JORE.0000011574.44362.8f

Masley, S. A., Gillanders, D. T., Simpson, S. G., & Taylor, M. A.. (2012). A systematic review of the evidence base for schema therapy. Cognitive Behaviour Therapy, 41(3), 185–202. https://doi.org/10.1080/16506073.2011.614274

Mesagno, C., Tibbert, S. J., Buchanan, E., Harvey, J. T., & Turner, M. J. (2021). Irrational beliefs and choking under pressure: A preliminary investigation. Journal of Applied Sport Psychology, 33(6), 569–589. https://doi.org/10.1080/10413200.2020.1737273

Samar, S. M., Walton, K. E., & Mcdermut, W. (2013). Personality traits predict irrational beliefs. Journal of Rational-emotive & Cognitive-behavior Therapy, 31(4), 231–242. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10942-013-0172-1

Tóth, R., Turner, M.J., Kökény, T., Tóth, L. (2022). “I must be perfect”: The role of irrational beliefs and perfectionism on the competitive anxiety of Hungarian athletes. Frontiers in Psychology, 13, 1-10. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2022.994126

Turner, M.J. (2016). Rational emotive behavior therapy (REBT), irrational and rational beliefs, and the mental health of athletes. Frontiers in Psychology, 7(1423), 1-16. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2016.01423

Turner, M. J., Aspin, G., & Gillman, J. (2019). Maladaptive schemas as a potential mechanism through which irrational beliefs relate to psychological distress in athletes. Psychology of Sport and Exercise, 44, 9–16. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.psychsport.2019.04.015

Turner, M. J., Ewen, D., & Barker, J. B.. (2020). An idiographic single-case study examining the use of rational emotive behavior therapy (REBT) with three amateur golfers to alleviate social anxiety. Journal of Applied Sport Psychology, 32(2), 186–204. https://doi.org/10.1080/10413200.2018.1496186

External links

Core beliefs: 12 worksheets to challenge negative beliefs (Positivepsychology.com)
Instant genius podcast: irrational thinking and beliefs, with Steven Pinker (BBC science focus)
Irrational beliefs (Youtube)
What are your irrational beliefs? (Psychology today)

Overview

Types of irrational beliefs

Demandingness

Depreciation

Frustration intolerance

Awfulising

Irrational beliefs and distress

Depression

Anger and aggression

Psychological motivators

Maladaptive schemas

Heuristics

Personality traits

Sociocultural motivators

The ABCDE model

Conclusion

See also

References

External links