Motivation and emotion/Book/2026/Self-blame and emotion
How does self-blame influence emotional responses to negative events?
Overview
[edit | edit source]Self-blame is a common response to negative experiences, but its emotional consequences are not always straightforward. While some individuals may use these experiences to reflect on their actions and consider what they could do differently, others may develop negative beliefs about themselves that contribute to ongoing emotional distress. Psychological research suggests that the way individuals interpret their responsibility for an event can influence both their emotional responses and how they approach similar situations in the future.
Understanding this relationship is important because self-blame is not necessarily helpful or harmful in every situation. Its consequences may depend on how individuals explain the event, whether they believe they have control over future outcomes, and whether their response encourages constructive action or repeated negative thinking.
This chapter examines how self-blame influences emotional responses following negative events. It explores the different forms of self-blame, psychological theories that explain the relationship between self-blame and emotion, and research examining its emotional consequences. It also considers the circumstances in which self-blame may encourage positive change or contribute to ongoing distress.
|
Focus questions
|
What is self-blame?
[edit | edit source]Self-blame occurs when someone believes they are responsible for a negative event or outcome. When something goes wrong, people often try to understand why it happened and whether they could have prevented it. Sometimes, this involves thinking about their own actions, while other times, they may question their personal abilities or characteristics. Although both involve blaming oneself, the difference is important because it may influence how much control someone believes they have over similar situations in the future.
What are the different forms of self-blame?
[edit | edit source]Janoff-Bulman (1979) distinguishes between the two forms of self-blame, behavioural self-blame and characterological self-blame. These differ based on whether a person blames something they did or something they believe is wrong with them as a person.
Behavioural self-blame:
[edit | edit source]Behavioural self-blame occurs when someone believes a negative event happened because of something they did or failed to do which directly impacted the outcome of the event. For example, an employee who misses an important work deadline may blame themselves for not managing their time effectively. Rather than believing they are incapable of doing their job, they recognise that their preparation or time management may have contributed to the outcome. Janoff-Bulman (1979) suggested that behavioural self-blame may help individuals maintain a sense of control because their actions can potentially be changed. If someone believes they could have prepared differently, they may also believe they can improve their approach next time. This does not mean that behavioural self-blame is always helpful, as someone may still feel guilty or continue blaming themselves for a mistake. Research by Anderson et al. (1994) challenges the assumption that behavioural self-blame is necessarily beneficial (see Figure 2).
|
Did you know 💡 Anderson et al. (1994) examined two samples of university students , involving 1,001 participants in total. Their findings indicated that both behavioural and characterological self-blame were associated with depression and loneliness. This suggests that focusing on one's actions rather than personal characteristics does not necessarily protect someone from emotional difficulties. |
Characterological self-blame:
[edit | edit source]Characterological self-blame occurs when someone believes a negative event happened because of their personal characteristics or abilities. Rather than focusing on a particular action, they may interpret the experience as evidence of something negative about themselves. For example, an employee who receives negative feedback from their manager may believe they are incompetent or simply not good enough at their job. Rather than considering whether there are specific areas they could improve, they interpret the feedback as evidence that they lack the personal abilities needed to succeed. Janoff-Bulman (1979) implied that characterological self-blame can be particularly distressing because people may view these characteristics as difficult to change. If someone believes the problem is part of who they are, they may feel that similar negative outcomes are likely to happen again.
This distinction helps explain why two people can blame themselves for a similar experience but respond differently. However, behavioural self-blame should not automatically be considered positive or characterological self-blame the only harmful form. Research by Anderson et al. (1994) suggests that both forms can be associated with emotional difficulties, meaning the consequences of self-blame may depend on more than what a person believes caused the event.
Choose your answers and click "Submit":
How do psychological theories explain the relationship between self-blame and emotion?
[edit | edit source]People do not always respond emotionally to negative experiences in the same way. Although two people may experience a similar situation, their emotions can differ depending on how they understand what happened. For example, two employees who make a mistake at work may both blame themselves, but one might feel guilty about their actions while the other feels ashamed of their abilities. This suggests that emotional responses are influenced not only by the negative event itself, but also by how a person explains and interprets it.
Two psychological approaches that help explain this relationship are attribution theory and cognitive appraisal theory. Whilst they focus on different aspects of emotional responses, both suggest that the meaning a person gives to a negative experience is important.
Attribution theory
[edit | edit source]Attribution theory focuses on how people explain why events happen. Weiner (1985) proposed that these explanations can be understood through three dimensions, locus, stability and controllability.
Locus refers to whether someone believes the cause of an event comes from themselves or from an external factor. Stability refers to whether the cause is seen as something temporary or likely to remain the same. Controllability considers whether the person believes they can influence the cause of the event. These dimensions help explain why self-blame can lead to different emotional responses. For example, someone who believes they missed an important deadline because they did not manage their time effectively may feel guilty but also believe they can prevent the same mistake in the future. However, someone who believes they missed the deadline because they are naturally incompetent may feel ashamed and less confident about improving.
Both individuals blame themselves, but they understand the cause of the mistake differently. This is important because Weiner's (1985) theory suggests that emotional responses depend partly on whether the perceived cause is stable and controllable, rather than simply whether a person believes they are responsible.
Cognitive appraisal theory
[edit | edit source]Cognitive appraisal theory focuses on how people evaluate the meaning of an experience. Rather than suggesting that an event automatically produces a particular emotion, this approach considers how an individual interprets the situation and what it means for them.
For example, receiving negative feedback on a sporting performance by a coach may be viewed as an opportunity to improve or as evidence of personal failure. Someone who believes the feedback identifies an area they can improve may feel disappointed but remain motivated. In comparison, someone who interprets the feedback as evidence they are not capable of succeeding may experience shame or anxiety about making further mistakes.
Tracy and Robins (2006) examined how different interpretations of negative experiences relate to guilt and shame . Their findings supported the idea that shame is more closely associated with explanations involving behaviours that can potentially be changed. This research helps explain why self-blame does not always produce the same emotional response. The way people understand their responsibility can influence whether they focus on correcting a particular mistake or develop more negative feelings about themselves.
Overall, attribution theory and cognitive appraisal theory help explain why self-blame can influence emotions differently. Attribution theory examines what people believe caused an event, while cognitive appraisal theory considers how they evaluate the meaning of the event. Together, these approaches suggest that understanding emotional responses to self-blame requires considering both the explanation for what happened and what that explanation means to the individual.
How do different forms of self-blame influence emotional responses?
[edit | edit source]Self-blame can be associated with several emotional responses, including guilt, shame, sadness and anxiety. However, these emotions are not necessarily experienced in the same way. The distinction between behavioural and characterological self-blame is important because it helps explain whether someone focuses on a particular mistake or develops negative beliefs about themselves. Research suggests that these different interpretations can influence both emotions and peoples experience and how they respond to negative events .
Guilt and shame
[edit | edit source]Guilt and shame are both emotions that can arise when someone believes they have done something wrong. However, guilt generally involves a negative evaluation of a particular action, while shame involves a negative evaluation of oneself.
For example, someone who forgets an important friend's birthday might feel guilty about being forgetful and decide to make it up to them. However, if they interpret the mistake as evidence that they are a terrible friend, they may experience shame. Although both reactions involve self-blame, the second involves a broader judgement about the person's character. Tracy and Robins (2006) found support for the relationship between different types of appraisals and experiences of guilt and shame. Their research suggests that shame is more closely associated with negative evaluations of the self, whereas guilt is more closely associated with evaluations of particular behaviours.
Tilghman-Osborne et al. (2008) further examined this relationship in a longitudinal study involving 221 adolescents . The researchers found that shame and characterological self-blame were closely related, suggesting that they may reflect a similar underlying pattern of negative self-evaluation. However, the relationship between guilt and behavioural self-blame was less consistent. This is important because it suggests that the distinction between the two forms of self-blame does not perfectly explain which emotion someone will experience. Although behavioural self-blame and guilt share similarities, they should not automatically be treated as the same experience.
Choose your answers and click "Submit":
Sadness, anxiety, and depressive symptoms
[edit | edit source]Beyond guilt and shame, self-blame may also contribute to broader emotional difficulties. When someone repeatedly interprets negative experiences as evidence of personal inadequacy, these beliefs may affect how they feel about themselves and their expectations for the future.
For example, a student who receives several disappointing grades might begin questioning their ability to succeed at university. Rather than feeling disappointed about one assessment, they may become increasingly discouraged and anxious about future results. This illustrates how negative self-evaluations can extend beyond an immediate emotional reaction. Janoff-Bulman (1979) found that depressed female university students reported greater characterological self-blame than non-depressed students, while behavioural self-blame did not differ significantly between the groups. This suggested that blaming negative experiences on personal characteristics may be particularly relevant to depressive symptoms.
However, subsequent research has complicated this distinction. Anderson et al. (1994) found associations between both forms of self-blame and emotional difficulties, including depression and loneliness. Similarly, Tilghman-Osborne et al. (2008) identified a significant relationship between shame, characterological self-blame and depressive symptoms among adolescents. Together, these studies suggest that negative judgements about the self may be particularly important in understanding depressive symptoms. However, they also show that behavioural self-blame should not automatically be considered harmless. The relationship may depend on how people interpret their responsibility and whether self-blame becomes a repeated pattern. There are also limitations to consider. Much of this research examines associations between self-blame and depressive symptoms rather than establishing a direct cause-and-effect relationship. The studies also involve different populations, including university students and adolescents, which may limit how broadly their findings can be applied.
Further evidence comes from Kim et al. (2011), who conducted a meta-analysis of 108 studies involving 22,411 participants. They found that shame had a stronger association with depressive symptoms (r = .43) than guilt (r = .28). However, guilt involving exaggerated responsibility for events beyond a person's control was also strongly associated with depressive symptoms (r = .39). These findings suggest that emotional difficulties may depend not only on whether someone experiences guilt or shame, but also on how they interpret their responsibility for a negative event.
Overall, research indicates that different forms of self-blame are related to emotional responses, particularly guilt, shame and depressive symptoms. However, the findings suggest that these relationships are more complex than simply associating behavioural self-blame with guilt and characterological self-blame with shame.
Under what circumstances might self-blame be helpful or harmful?
[edit | edit source]The consequences of self-blame may depend on what happens after someone accepts responsibility for a negative experience. In some situations, recognising a mistake can encourage reflection and improvement. In others, blaming oneself may make it more difficult to move forward, especially when the person continues focusing on what went wrong. Understanding the difference is important because recognising responsibility does not necessarily lead to a helpful emotional response.
When self-blame encourages constructive change
[edit | edit source]Self-blame may be helpful when someone uses the experience to identify what they could do differently in the future. For example, a person who performs poorly in a job interview might recognise that they did not prepare enough. Although they may feel disappointed, they can use this experience to practise their interview skills and approach future opportunities differently.
Research by Tangney et al. (2007) suggests that guilt can encourage constructive responses following negative experiences. Their review discusses how guilt is often associated with taking responsibility and attempting to repair mistakes, such as apologising after hurting someone. This suggests that recognising responsibility may encourage positive change when attention is directed towards what can be done differently in the future. However, guilt is not necessarily helpful when someone takes responsibility for circumstances beyond their control. An important factor is whether the person believes they have control over what happens next. Weiner's (1985) attribution theory suggests that perceived controllability influences how people respond to negative outcomes. If someone believes their actions can make a difference, recognising a mistake may encourage them to take steps towards improving the situation.
However, there is a difference between accepting responsibility and unnecessarily blaming oneself. Recognising that a particular decision contributed to an outcome can be useful, but this does not mean that a person needs to continue feeling guilty to make a positive change. What may be helpful is the opportunity to learn from the experience, rather than the negative emotion itself.
When self-blame contributes to ongoing distress
[edit | edit source]Self-blame may become harmful when someone repeatedly thinks about a negative experience without reaching a useful conclusion. Instead of identifying a way forward, they may continue questioning what they should have done differently. This pattern resembles rumination, which involves repeatedly focusing on distressing experiences and their possible causes or consequences. Nolen-Hoeksema et al. (2008) reviewed research showing that rumination is associated with prolonged negative mood and greater vulnerability to depressive symptoms. Although rumination and self-blame are not the same process, the findings help explain why repeatedly revisiting perceived personal mistakes may contribute to ongoing emotional difficulties.
The potential harm of self-blame is not limited to repeatedly thinking about negative experiences. Frazier (1990) found that both behavioural and characterological self-blame were associated with greater depressive symptoms among women who had experienced sexual assault. These findings challenge the assumption that focusing on one's behaviour is necessarily less harmful than blaming personal characteristics. However, because the study examined responses to a traumatic experience, its findings may not apply in the same way to everyday mistakes or disappointing performance. Another concern is that people do not always accurately judge how much responsibility they had for an event. For example, someone whose friendship ends may blame themselves entirely, even though the relationship was influenced by both people. If they overlook circumstances outside their control, their self-blame may reinforce feelings of guilt or inadequacy without helping them understand what happened. This highlights an important limitation in treating self-blame as a way of improving future outcomes. Even when someone believes they could have prevented an event, that belief does not necessarily mean they had the ability to do so. Self-blame may therefore be particularly unhelpful when it involves unrealistic responsibility or repeated negative thoughts that do not lead to constructive action.
Overall, the distinction between helpful and harmful self-blame is not simply whether someone accepts responsibility. It also depends on whether that responsibility is realistic, whether the person has control over future outcomes, and whether reflecting on the experience encourages constructive action. Recognising a mistake may provide an opportunity for change, whereas repeatedly blaming oneself for circumstances beyond one's control may prolong emotional distress.
Conclusion
[edit | edit source]Self-blame is more complex than simply believing that a negative event was one's own fault. How individuals interpret their responsibility can influence the emotions they experience, particularly when they attribute an outcome to their behaviour or personal characteristics. The distinction between behavioural and characterological self-blame helps explain why people may respond differently to similar experiences. Attribution theory and cognitive appraisal theory further demonstrate that emotional responses are influenced not only by what happens, but also by how individuals understand the cause and meaning of an event.
Research highlights the relationship between self-blame and emotions such as guilt, shame and depressive symptoms. While behavioural self-blame is often considered more constructive because it focuses on actions that may be changed, the evidence suggests that this distinction is not always straightforward. Both forms of self-blame have been associated with emotional difficulties, challenging the assumption that focusing on one's behaviour necessarily protects against distress. Similarly, although guilt may encourage individuals to take responsibility and repair mistakes, it can also become distressing when someone assumes responsibility for circumstances beyond their control.
Ultimately, whether self-blame is helpful or harmful may depend on how realistically individuals assess their responsibility and what they do with that understanding. Recognising a mistake may encourage reflection and positive change, particularly when future outcomes can be influenced by different actions. However, repeated negative thoughts or blaming oneself for uncontrollable circumstances may contribute to ongoing emotional distress. Understanding these differences is important because it shows that taking responsibility does not have to involve continued self-criticism. Instead, learning from negative experiences may be more constructive when individuals recognise what they can change without assuming responsibility for everything that went wrong.
See also
[edit | edit source]
References
[edit | edit source]Anderson, C. A., et al. “Behavioral and Characterological Attributional Styles as Predictors of Depression and Loneliness: Review, Refinement, and Test.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, vol. 66, no. 3, 1 Mar. 1994, pp. 549–558, https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/8169764/
Frazier, P. A. (1990). Victim attributions and post-rape trauma. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 59(2), 298–304. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.59.2.298
Janoff-Bulman, R. (1979).Characterological versus behavioral self-blame: Inquiries into depression and rape. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 37(10), 1798–1809. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.37.10.1798
Kim, S., Thibodeau, R., & Jorgensen, R. S. (2011). Shame, guilt, and depressive symptoms: A meta-analytic review. Psychological Bulletin, 137(1), 68–96. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0021466
Lazarus, R. S. (1991). Emotion and adaptation. Oxford University Press.
National Study of Mental Health and Wellbeing, 2020-21. (2022, July 22). Australian Bureau of Statistics. https://www.abs.gov.au/statistics/health/mental-health/national-study-mental-health-and-wellbeing/2020-21?utm_
Nolen-Hoeksema, S., Wisco, B. E., & Lyubomirsky, S. (2008). Rethinking rumination. Perspectives on Psychological Science, 3(5), 400–424. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1745-6924.2008.00088.x
Peterson, C., Schwartz, S. M., & Seligman, M. E. P. (1981). Self-blame and depressive symptoms. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 41(2), 253–259. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.41.2.253
Tangney, J. P., Stuewig, J., & Mashek, D. J. (2007).Moral emotions and moral behavior. Annual Review of Psychology, 58, 345–372. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev.psych.56.091103.070145
Tilghman-Osborne, C., Cole, D. A., Felton, J. W., & Ciesla, J. A. (2008). Relation of guilt, shame, behavioral and characterological self-blame to depressive symptoms in adolescents over time. Journal of Social and Clinical Psychology, 27(8), 809–842. https://doi.org/10.1521/jscp.2008.27.8.809
Tracy, J. L., & Robins, R. W. (2006).Appraisal antecedents of shame and guilt: Support for a theoretical model. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 32(10), 1339–1351. https://doi.org/10.1177/0146167206290212
Weiner, B. (1985).An attributional theory of achievement motivation and emotion. Psychological Review, 92(4), 548–573. https://doi.org/10.1037/0033-295X.92.4.548
External links
[edit | edit source]- Unhelpful thinking styles (Government of Western Australia)
- Self-blame (Psychology tools)
- Understanding the effects of trauma (Mind)
