User:Egm6322.s09/Report table/Best of report R2
From Wikiversity
Under construction; not final (but close to being stable after a couple of weeks). The intention here is to document the best features in any report for the readers (including you); if you see any excellent features in any of the reports (including your team's) that I may have missed noticing, don't hesitate to let me know. I don't have time to read all reports in detail. Due to time constraint, I would only selectively looked at a few important features. I also added some annotations (e.g., related to errors, improvements, etc.) where I looked through for the benefit of everyone. Egm6322.s09 12:18, 7 February 2009 (UTC)
Latest archived version (possibly with comments): Team Bit Team Mafia Team Three
- classnotes (including simple HW problems), graded over 100%
- 2nd-order quasilinear PDEs
- examples
- verification of linearity
- 2nd-order linear PDEs
- matrix-operator form
- constant coefficients
- varying coefficients
- equivalence between two forms: regular form and matrix form
- HW: Condition for equality of mixed derivatives
. Best solution: Team Bit simpler to understand; Team Mafia the proof is a bit more complicated to read, but essentially the same. Note: Team Three good starting point, which coincides with the proofs in the other two reports, but need to use mean-value-theorem to conclude, and can use different step size along
and
to be more general as in the proofs in the other two reports; appears to do this proof on their own; good. - linearity of diffusion operator
- linearity of derivative. Best solution: Team Mafia. Note: Team Bit Team Three gave a statement, but not a proof.
- linearity of gradient operator
- linearity of divergence operator
- HW: Condition for equality of mixed derivatives
- nonlinear transformation of coordinates
- matrix-operator form in new coordinates
- linearity, 2 definitions
- definition 1 in class
- definition 2 in Kolmogorov & Fomin, Selvadurai
- additivity
- homogeneity
- examples of linear maps in higher dimensions, matrices, homogeneity
- transformation of coordinates, rotation of coordinate system. Best solution: Team Bit see better explanation in class. Note: Team Mafia only display the rotation matrix, and referred to a book, but not derived it. Team Three did not do this problem.
- affine mappings, not linear; example, rotation and translation
- equivalence between two definitions, proof
- sufficient condition
- necessary condition
. Best solution:
and
to be more general as in the proofs in the other two reports; appears to do this proof on their own; good.